It’s not a terrific look when simply the second-ever movie in your burgeoning superhero universe arrives with a poor Rotten Tomatoes rating. That’s simply occurred to Supergirl, which presently has a 57% from nearly 150 critics.
These Supergirl opinions put it properly beneath the 83% of Superman, and it’s getting into a market the place there are precisely three rotten-scored MCU films out of three dozen or so, Captain America: Courageous New World, Eternals and Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania, if we’re evaluating it to DC’s direct rival. To be truthful, the DCEU, the previous internet of movies, had practically half of its films land rotten scores. Although the thought was that the DCU can be higher than the previous universe, which unceremoniously fizzled out.
Field workplace returns should not projected to be significantly better, and Supergirl will likely be fortunate if it makes half of what Superman did, maybe round $300 million, perilously low within the style. Now, some are turning towards James Gunn and, even after simply two films, questioning his capability to guide the DCU as its total architect, whether or not that’s truthful or not.
Is it? Effectively, I definitely suppose we are able to say that James Gunn is aware of easy methods to make high quality superhero films/exhibits himself. His resume:
- Guardians of the Galaxy (directed and co-written) – 91% critic rating
- Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (directed and co-written) – 85% critic rating
- Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 (directed and co-written) – 82% critic rating
- Guardians of the Galaxy Vacation Particular (directed and co-written) – 95% critic rating
- The Suicide Squad (directed and written) – 90% critic rating
- Peacemaker (utterly written and majority directed) – 93% critic rating
- Creature Commandos (created and utterly written) – 95% critics rating
- Superman (directed and written) – 83% critic rating
NEW YORK, NEW YORK – JUNE 22: (L-R) Craig Gillespie, Peter Safran, Milly Alcock and James Gunn attend the premiere of “Supergirl” on June 22, 2026 in New York Metropolis. (Picture by Theo Wargo/Getty Photographs)
Getty Photographs
Viewers scores for many of those are excessive, if not increased. Gunn has the golden contact, however the key phrase there’s “contact.” Supergirl is his first “supervised” film that he neither directed (that was Craig Gillespie) or wrote (that was Ana Nogueira). And it’s the lowest-scored of the above by a major margin.
The query not is just not whether or not Gunn’s capability as a filmmaker is unsure, however whether or not he’ll be making the correct calls on initiatives he doesn’t straight have a hand in writing or directing. Quotes are resurfacing during which Gunn says he’ll solely transfer ahead with a challenge if the script is “rock strong.” Many would say that’s removed from the case with Supergirl, and now there’s an extra concern that Gunn has Supergirl author Ana Nogueira writing each Teen Titans and the all-important Marvel Lady to come back.
Then there are additional flashbacks to 2023, when Gunn praised the DCEU’s The Flash to excessive heaven, even calling it “one of many biggest films ever made.” The Flash arrived with a 63% critic rating, spawned plenty of memes, and misplaced extra money on the field workplace than nearly every other superhero film ever. Then, Gunn employed that film’s director, Andy Muschietti, to direct the DCU’s Batman: The Courageous and the Daring. So, uh, you may be capable to see the priority.
It’s too early. That’s the conclusion I draw regardless of all this. We will’t be two movies into the DCU and write off your entire challenge due to one miss. There are extra exams to come back, lots of them imminent, just like the HBO Max Lanterns collection and the upcoming horror challenge Clayface this fall. Nobody expects the R-rated, area of interest horror Clayface to be some form of field workplace blockbuster, however the subsequent movie after that’s Gunn’s personal Superman sequel, Man of Tomorrow, the place that gained’t take a look at his “outsourcing skills,” which we might not see once more in earnest till 2028, no matter that 12 months brings.
The Supergirl opinions should not good. The field workplace is shaping as much as be not good. I do perceive the priority about Gunn’s selections and previous opinions, which appear to distinction with the standard of his personal work, however we have to see extra earlier than rendering an precise verdict. Although it’s unclear how a lot time Warner Bros. might give him, particularly if the Paramount takeover involves move, and so they need higher outcomes. However we’re going to see how this all performs out over the following few years, and earlier than that, this weekend.
Observe me on Twitter, YouTube, and Instagram.
Choose up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller collection and The Earthborn Trilogy.
